The Rise of Game and Media Piracy: An Inevitable Backlash?

With the advent of streaming services like Netflix and gaming platforms like Xbox Game Pass, media piracy saw a significant decline. These services provided affordable and convenient access to vast libraries of content, reducing the need for consumers to seek out pirated versions. However, in recent years, a new trend has emerged.

The mantra “buying isn’t ownership, so pirating isn’t stealing” is gaining traction as consumers face an overwhelming number of streaming services and rising subscription costs.

Advertisements

The Fragmentation of Streaming Services

Initially, services like Netflix offered a one-stop shop for a wide range of movies and TV shows. As the streaming landscape has fragmented, with companies like Disney, Warner Bros., and Amazon creating their own platforms, consumers are now required to subscribe to multiple services to access the content they want. This has led to a significant increase in the overall cost of accessing media legally.

Gaming Subscriptions: A Growing Expense

Similar trends are evident in the gaming industry. Subscription services like Xbox Live, PlayStation Network, and Game Pass have seen price increases. While these services still offer value, the cumulative cost can be prohibitive, especially for gamers who want access to multiple platforms.

Subscription Price Increases in AUD

Here’s a look at the current and old prices for some popular streaming and gaming services in Australian dollars:

The Return of Piracy

As the number of subscriptions and their costs have increased, so has the appeal of piracy. Consumers are frustrated with the need to juggle multiple subscriptions and the perception that they never truly own the content they pay for. Piracy, once on the decline, is seeing a resurgence as a direct response to these market conditions.

The Impact of Digital Marketplaces and Game Sunsetting

The issue extends beyond streaming services to the gaming industry, where digital marketplaces like Steam, PlayStation Store, and Xbox Live have become the primary means of distributing games. However, these platforms are also subject to sunsetting and content removal, leaving players unable to purchase or download legacy games. This has led to a significant backlash from the gaming community, which feels that ownership of purchased content is being eroded.

When games are removed from digital stores, consumers lose access to titles they may have previously purchased or intended to buy. This trend undermines the traditional notion of ownership, where once you bought a physical copy of a game, it was yours indefinitely. In the digital era, corporations can revoke access at any time, leaving consumers at the mercy of platform policies and licensing agreements.

Example: The recent closure of the PlayStation Store for PlayStation 3 and PSP titles highlighted this issue. Many games became inaccessible, leading to a rush of purchases before the store’s shutdown and sparking debates about digital ownership.

Legal and Ethical Considerations

While piracy is illegal and undermines the revenue of content creators, the industry’s shift towards fragmented, high-cost access models has alienated a portion of the consumer base. The notion that “buying isn’t ownership” reflects a growing dissatisfaction with digital rights management (DRM) practices that limit how and where content can be accessed, even after purchase.

A Way Forward

To combat the rise in piracy, the media and gaming industries need to rethink their approach. Consolidating content into fewer, more comprehensive services at reasonable prices could help. Additionally, improving the value proposition of subscriptions by ensuring consumers feel a sense of ownership and control over their purchases is crucial.

For gaming, this could mean ensuring that once a game is purchased, it remains available for download indefinitely, even if the digital marketplace sunsets. Alternatively, providing DRM-free versions or allowing community-hosted servers for online games could help preserve access.

The battle against piracy will require a balanced approach that addresses consumer frustrations while protecting the rights and revenues of content creators. As the market evolves, finding this balance will be key to maintaining a healthy, sustainable ecosystem for digital media and gaming.